Skip to content

Critical, major and minor defects: how to classify them

Without a clear classification, the same defect is “major” for one inspector and “minor” for another, and the lot result depends on who inspects it.

The three classes

The class says how much the defect weighs in the lot decision.

  • Critical: may harm the user or breaks a legal or safety requirement.
  • Major: affects the use, durability or saleability of the product. The customer would probably return it.
  • Minor: departs from the standard without affecting use. The customer may notice it but would keep the product.

Examples by industry

The same logic works for any product. What changes is each product's list of defects.

  • Apparel: broken needle in the garment (critical), open seam (major), loose thread (minor).
  • Footwear: nail or staple exposed inside (critical), sole coming off (major), glue stain (minor).
  • Electronics: exposed live part (critical), product doesn't turn on (major), light scratch on the housing (minor).
  • Furniture: sharp edge or loose hardware that can injure (critical), part that doesn't fit (major), slight shade difference (minor).

How to build the defect catalog

The catalog is the single list of defects every inspector uses. It avoids free-text descriptions nobody can compare.

  • Give each defect a unique name and an objective description.
  • Set each defect's class in the catalog, not during inspection.
  • Use reference photos of what is and what isn't a defect.
  • Group defects by category, such as sewing, finishing and packaging, to find them fast.
  • Agree on the catalog with the customer or supplier before inspecting.

From class to lot result

Each class gets its own criterion in the sampling plan. A common combination is zero tolerance for critical, AQL 2.5 for major and 4.0 for minor defects. In the sample, each class is counted separately, and one class reaching its rejection number is enough to reject the lot.

See Traqer in your inspection process.

In 30 minutes, we show you how to set up a checklist template and a sampling plan for one of your products.

Book your free demo

30 min · no commitment · reply within 1 business day